Jeanette Bicknell's Philosophy of Song and Singing is a convincing addition to the body of work in musical aesthetics, which has tended to emphasize music alone. Song and Singing offers a framework for understanding singing, itself, that is philosophically solid, yet very accessible for undergraduates in all specializations who are interested in exploring more about the nature of musical performance.
Jennifer Judkins, UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music, USA
Even very simple songs can yield profound (and profoundly moving) performances, and Jeanette Bicknell's A Philosophy of Song and Singing is an engaging exploration of songs and their performance. Written with admirable clarity, this is an important contribution to the aesthetics of music.
Theodore Gracyk, Minnesota State University Moorhead, USA
Bicknell has thought long, hard, and lovingly about song and its place in our lives, and the results on display in this book are as refreshing as they are provocative.
Jerrold Levinson, University of Maryland, USA
Bicknell's book considers not only 'purely musical' matters of singing and vocal technique but also the larger social, political, and cultural contexts in which the various practices of singing arise and are enjoyed, including such diverse matters as the public persona and physical appearance of singers and the roles that digital technologies such as Auto-Tune play in the expectations of singers and audiences. A Philosophy of Song and Singing is an important contribution to the philosophical literature on song and singing.
Philip Alperson, Temple University, USA
Bicknell's erudition is impressive. The book is scholarly yet accessible to undergraduate students. When philosophers and theories are mentioned, they are followed by precise, brief expositions. Thus, the book is appropriate for students with little or no background in philosophy. Its brevity and concision are also virtues for teaching. For those looking for expanding standard, core aesthetics courses with an interesting, specific subfield, or for those focusing on music, this book is a welcome addition and an affordable option for its brevity (it does not add too much to one's already hefty or crowded syllabus). If one is looking for a way to incorporate popular art forms and genres into one's aesthetics syllabus, then this book is a good choice. For courses emphasizing the philosophy of the performing arts, this book may be used with David Davies's Philosophy of the Performing Arts. Even philosophy of language courses could benefit from such a book, since the book addresses some issues in vocalization, pragmatics, sociolinguistics, and meaning.
--Tobyn Demarco in Teaching Philosophy
Jeanette Bicknell's Philosophy of Song and Singing is a convincing addition to the body of work in musical aesthetics, which has tended to emphasize music alone. Song and Singing offers a framework for understanding singing, itself, that is philosophically solid, yet very accessible for undergraduates in all specializations who are interested in exploring more about the nature of musical performance.
--Jennifer Judkins, UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music, USA
Even very simple songs can yield profound (and profoundly moving) performances, and Jeanette Bicknell's A Philosophy of Song and Singing is an engaging exploration of songs and their performance. Written with admirable clarity, this is an important contribution to the aesthetics of music.
--Theodore Gracyk, Minnesota State University Moorhead, USA
Bicknell has thought long, hard, and lovingly about song and its place in our lives, and the results on display in this book are as refreshing as they are provocative.
--Jerrold Levinson, University of Maryland, USA
Bicknell's book considers not only 'purely musical' matters of singing and vocal technique but also the larger social, political, and cultural contexts in which the various practices of singing arise and are enjoyed, including such diverse matters as the public persona and physical appearance of singers and the roles that digital technologies such as Auto-Tune play in the expectations of singers and audiences. A Philosophy of Song and Singing is an important contribution to the philosophical literature on song and singing.
--Philip Alperson, Temple University, USA
This accessible work is an important addition to philosophical literature on singing. Summing Up: Recommended.
- S. C. Champagne, Oberlin College Conservatory of Music in CHOICE
