For other novelists the value of Henry James's Notebooks is immense and to brood over them a major experience. The glow of the great impresario is on the pages. They are occasionally readable and endlessly stimulating, often moving and are ocasionally relieved by a drop of gossip.-V. S. Pritchett, New Statesman

The Notebooks take us into his study, and here we can observe him, at last, in the very act of creation at his writing table.-Leon Edel, Atlantic Monthly

A document of prime importance.-Edmund Wilson, New Yorker