Emma has asked to borrow back her lost tooth to show her grandmother. But the Tooth Fairy keeps bringing the wrong ones, and the animals have to come to claim them back! Emma has just lost her first tooth, and the tooth fairy has taken it away. When Emma's grandfather comes to visit, she asks if she can borrow back the tooth to show him. But the tooth fairy brings the wrong tooth, and a rhinoceros comes to claim it back. And then the tooth fairy brings another wrong tooth, and another, and another...