Magnificent and tragic.... Sharfstein is a wonderful storyteller with a deep knowledge of all the relevant source material from the period. His narrative is rich with fascinating historical details. -- Nick Romeo - Christian Science Monitor
Intimate, propulsive and ultimately heart-breaking... a compassionate military history and a shrewd examination of how cultural legends are created. -- Julie M. Klein - Chicago Tribune
A brisk narrative of one of the last major collisions between Native Americans and white America. [Sharfstein's] two main characters are complex and compelling-Chief Joseph, a thoughtful, powerful speaker who spent years trying to find a way for his people to live alongside American settlers, and General O.O. Howard, a moralistic liberal Army general whose fate it was to crush Joseph's small Nez Perce tribe. -- Thomas E. Ricks - New York Times Book Review
Solidly researched, well-written and engaging. -- Dallas Morning News
An excellent new book.... Many of us shake our heads endlessly at the shabby treatment our ancestors rendered on Indians even as we enjoy the lands stolen from them. Would our leaders have handled the situation that much differently today? Would we object? And how does that relate to how we now treat some other oppressed people, immigrants, including refugees fleeing war-torn countries our nation has failed to help pacify? Sharfstein raises those questions well in Thunder in the Mountains. -- John Railey - Winston-Salem Journal
A thorough and well-documented work of history [that] delves into the human condition like the best fiction, offering insights not only into historical events but also into the ways people can grow and evolve. -- Memphis Commercial Appeal
Sharfstein presents his view without polemic. Indeed, the writing is lyrical-smooth and engaging, albeit with scrupulous bibliographical notes to underscore its historical authenticity.... Sharfstein shows how at each interaction with federal authorities and their texts, Joseph focused on understanding not so much the particular words as the mechanisms through which 'authoritative' documents were created, trying to find his way in the wilderness of American power. -- Peter d'Errico - Indian Country Today
An important book that will doubtless enjoy a broad readership among the general public and should be read by students as well as specialists interested in the Civil War era, military history, the history of the American West, and indigenous studies. -- Pacific Northwest Quarterly
Brilliant... a timeless parable of two pious men who served, led and fought with honor and dignity for their nation's causes.... Sharfstein's Thunder in the Mountains will resonate loudly and remind readers that basic human rights in a democracy should never be taken for granted. -- Stuart Rosebrook - True West
A good post-Independence Day read in the sense that it really does show the scope of U.S. power, who makes certain decisions about the rights of native peoples, the meaning of liberty and equality and its relationship to ethnicity, color, place, and class. -- Dana Williams - The Takeaway
Daniel Sharfstein offers a searing account of an American tragedy: how Oliver Otis Howard, a champion for the rights of freed slaves, became an architect of the dispossession and subjugation of Native people. This beautifully written book will change the way readers think about the era of Civil War and Reconstruction. -- Ari Kelman, author of A Misplaced Massacre: Struggling Over the Memory of Sand Creek
