At last a comprehensive, historically deep and ecologically knowledgeable study of a great dam. The Isaacmans brilliantly show how, all along the Zambezi below the Cahora Bassa Dam, whole worlds of riparian life-fish, birds, humans and other mammals-dependent on the annual inundation of the flood plain have been stilled. They recover the voices silenced by the fear and violence deployed by states devoted to the care and feeding of this mega-project. Unparalleled in its sweep, depth and attention to the lived experience of all its victims.
...This book is a passionate and richly documented critique of a disastrous high-modernist scheme, concerned not only to challenge the triumphalist narrative of Cahora Bassa, but equally, to argue against the newest delusion of development as Mozambique seeks to build a second dam downstream. It is a welcome addition to the literature on large dam projects in Africa, and opens up rich possibilities of comparison around the continent. * International Journal of African Historical Studies *
What I find most illuminating in this text is the authors'
nuanced assessment of oral evidence from interviews
with workers, party officials, and rural residents
who experienced changes in their lives as the dam
wrought new ecologies. In particular, they
recognize and describe collected oral texts (mainly living
memory) as significant social texts with hidden,
multiple, and often contradictory meanings.
* American Historical Review *
Cahora Bassa has always been more than just a hydrological project and Allen and Barbara Isaacman expertly explore how Portugal exerted authority and sought to legitimise their control over the local population...through the construction of a hydroelectric mega scheme.... The Isaacmans provide an excellent and authoritative understanding of the different displacements that have occurred through Cahora Bassa and this book is an important and comprehensive study which will remain a major source for scholars. * The Journal of Modern African Studies *
[Dams, Displacement, and the Delusion of Development] is bound to become a classic in the literature on dams and large-scale development schemes and deserves a wide readership, including beyond academic circles.
Cahora Bassa embodies disturbing continuities from colonial developmentalism in current economic planning, including coerced labor and forced resettlement. As veteran Mozambicanists, Allen Isaacman and Barbara Isaacman draw on decades of research, also making use of numerous environmental assessments of the dam's ecological effects. A great strength of the book comes from presenting many voices of peasants, fisherfolk, and dam workers who speak eloquently about lost lands, rights, and livelihoods. Essential for African and development studies collections. * Choice *
[
Dams, Displacement and the Delusion of Development], which is rich with first-hand quotes of people directly impacted by the massive scheme, analyzes the social, environmental and economic failures of this huge dam project. A picture emerges of a river being used as a political football in a time of waning colonial power, and a project fraught with injustices.... This excellent study offers a cautionary tale for those who would build new destructive large dams on the Zambezi River. * World Rivers Review *
The Isaacmans' book is a classic, comprehensive account of how a large dam, in this case Mozambique's most important 'development' project when completed, initiated a large-scale land and water grab that has adversely, and unacceptably, affected the livelihood of hundreds of thousands of people living in the lower Zambezi Basin.
Isaacman and Isaacman provide a wrenching alternative story from the perspective of peasants, fishermen, and workers whose lives were deeply and irreparably impacted by the dam. [A] major corrective to debates about the benefits of big development projects.
