If there is one book to read on what shaped American policy toward the Soviet Union in its last years and Russia throughout the last decade, this is it. It offers more than a narrative; it offers an explanation within a very useful conceptual framework. It understands that policy is not made either in a vacuum or by simple bureaucratic imperatives. It is the product of ideas and real people who embrace those ideas. The pull between those who believed we could and should transform Russia and those who focused principally on the security dimensions of the relationship has, to differing degrees, shaped the policies of the first Bush, Clinton, and current Bush administrations. That reality, and the lessons to be learned from it, are thoroughly explored in this superb book. - Ambassador Dennis B. Ross
|
The authors... have documented their topic well.... The book discusses three US administrations, those run by Father and Son Bush, and Bill Clinton. Goldgeier and McFaul emphasize the difference in purpose between these three administrations.... This book stands out as a seminal work. It is likely to last because of its eminent sources and judicious assessments, and it is well edited and a pleasant read. -Anders Aslund, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, International Affairs, 5/1/2004
|
James Goldgeier of George Washington University and Michael McFaul of Stanford University have done an admirable job chronicling the Russia policies of the first Bush, Clinton, and second Bush administrations.... Using extensive interviews with participants in all three administrations, and memoirs by former officials, they paint a compelling picture of officials often overwhelmed by the challenge of an entirely new reality. -Angela E Stent, World Policy Journal, 12/1/2003
|
This book gives the reader more than its title indicates. Its authors trace U.S. policy in conjunction with both Russian foreign policy and changes in Russian democratization, human rights issues, and economic development from the late 1980s into 2003. -Peter Juviler, Political Science Quarterly
|
POWER AND PURPOSE provides the best coverage of this crucial issue that I have read. Combining a thorough narrative with incisive analysis, Goldgeier and McFaul present clearly the making of U.S. policies toward Russia in recent years -where we got it right and where we should have
done much better. A real contribution and a good read as well.
-Anthony Lake, former National Security Adviser
|
POWER AND PURPOSE is likely to be the definitive work on U.S. policy toward Russia for some time. What is more, the authors have produced a valuable book that underscores an often overlooked reality, namely, that few foreign policy outcomes are inevitable and that people -in some cases, only a handful -are critical to what happens. -Richard N. Haass, President, Council on Foreign Relations