Its rare that I have such an immediate response to, and impression made by, a work of fiction but occasionally a novel comes along which is that pleasurable you almost feel compelled to return immediately to the first page and begin again. That is the minimum level of praise that The Queens Lender warrants; in all honesty, it deserves a great deal more. If this novel does not win a major award in the next publishing cycle, it will be a travesty and a disservice to the talents and intelligence of the author. Im effusive and unashamed in writing such a review.
Meet George Heriot, the Queens Lender. Based in Edinburgh, Heriot is a goldsmith by trade, royal-appointed jeweller and subsequently a philanthropist. A detail which the author brings to attention is that the role of the goldsmith in the seventeenth century was not just to produce jewels and precious metals but also to fulfil a number of other financial services to the monarch, thus Heriot becomes the Queens Banker. Mr Heriot holds the ear of the Queen as well as the purse strings, and both provide him with sufficient information and strategic knowledge to ensure that his fortune is made, yet despite this he serves dutifully and ably. Discretion sits well with debt in this case and whilst Heriot is depicted as a loyal servant, the reader is in no way deluded that Heriots main priority is the preservation of himself and his family.
Heriot ascends the ranks of the court, initially selling items to Anne of Denmark (Queen Consort) before his appointment to serve the Queen. Annes reputation for her love of jewellery is portrayed well, as is the lavish spending which was undertaken by her and James VI. What is significant about this portrayal of Heriot is the manner in which it illustrates how his philanthropic activity and considerations were borne out of concerns about the spendthrift and extravagant nature of the monarchys activities. He hears: the Masque of Blackness cost over 100,000 enough to build a palace, or to educate the whole of Edinburgh. It is at this point Findlay is able to offer Heriots counterpoint to the significant wealth he accrues and benefits from due to such expenditure.
Findlay is able to depict the tales of each critical member of the ruling family and their critical roles in the formation of the United Kingdom with a tenderness and humanity that is often markedly juxtaposed against the violence and brutality which characterised the court of James VI of Scotland. The young boy subjected to a brutal glossectomy for praying with a rosary is a harrowing but tender scene that sticks long in the memory.
Annes lack of financial acumen, Jamess paranoia about witchcraft and his subsequent purging of East Lothian, the appointment of the grandiloquent Shakespeare as Court Playwright and the broader commentary on the relationship between Europe and the United Kingdom gives this novel a timely resonance on the principles that history doesnt repeat itself, it simply rhymes. As Ben Jonson is heard to say: We English need separation, independence, none of your wet alliances with Spain England has never liked Europe We do not need them, we can fight the world alone. From the need to move away from ones home in order to prosper to the political division and nepotism which dominates, this astute piece of fiction is both in and out of its time.
The elegance of Findlays documenting this figure is enhanced by the laser-focused attention to his troubled private life as a father and husband who was often bereft of his wife and children by circumstances beyond his control, including death in childbirth and a childless marriage. At the point of Union and James Is decision to move to London, we see Heriots concern as to the consequence of his wifes travelling to London. This is a sequence where Findlays ability to bring the subject of her fiction to life, a touching and humane set of exchanges where the dialogue and scene-setting is delightful. She excels in conveying the environment and interrelationship between that and the emotions experienced by the characters, whether the reader is in the privacy of the Queens own chamber, a pungent fishmonger within the lively atmosphere of an Edinburgh street, an aromatic garden, or a claustrophobic and unsettled cabin in a ship sailing at the mercies of sea.
There is much more that could be said about The Queens Lender but this will hopefully sufficiently whet the appetite for the sumptuous feast of fiction that lies ahead for curious readers. Mr Heriots legacy has lived on through Heriots Hospital, George Heriots School and Heriot-Watt University. I expect that reputation to be burnished by this marvellous account of his life and the circumstances in which he lived.
-- Martyn Colebrook * 'The Queen's Lender' by Jean Findlay *
In The Queens Lender Jean Findlay gives us a wonderful insight into life in 17th century Edinburgh and London, and in particular the extravagant, intrigue-ridden, courts of James Stuart and his Danish consort, Anna.The story begins in 1593, when both the Kings and George Heriots wives are pregnant. Queen Anna, who is just 17 years old, loves jewels, and James desperate for an heir is ready to indulge her every whim, so Heriot is a frequent visitor to the palace. He and his own wife, Christian, live above his workshop in Fishmarket Close.It is past midnight and the Royal Mile is brisk with life. Shouts and laughter, the hum of warm and ribald talk in the tavern next door. A slice of fiddle music each time the door opensFishmarket Close, a smelly wynd but narrow and steep so the bones and guts from the fish shops will sluice downhill in the rain.
Findlay excels in conveying the nature of a place, be it the Queens own private chamber, an Edinburgh close, a fragrant garden, or a claustrophobic cabin in a ship at sea. We are there, we smell the flowers and the fish, we see the vomit.Heriots life will run in parallel with Annas; for he is not only an acclaimed jeweller, who loves precious stones for their beauty rather than their acquisition, but also a canny man of business. Through all the ups, and the many downs, of his working life he will keep meticulous accounts, and he is shrewd in his dealings with the court. No sooner has he made a new piece for Anna or James than every courtier wants one; fashion is all. At the palace clothes and jewellery convey not only rank and status; they send messages. Everything is symbolic. Ambitious courtiers compete to assert their importance; Heriot charges them in advance, and far more than he charges the King. His wealth increases. Anna gives his rings as gifts to visiting ambassadors; his work is seen all over Europe.
Anna, meanwhile, has no idea about money, so Heriot lends it to her. It comes back to him as payment for his work, and he still owns the debt, carefully recorded in his ledgers. He becomes, in fact, her private banker. George may bear physical similarities to Annas James:
But (he is) a much gentler version, and one that listens.
And there is one more glaring difference: Heriot balances his books, while the King and Queen spend with reckless abandon, which in the end cannot fail to lead to trouble.
These are violent times and the King is permanently suspicious (as well he might be, given the fate of his mother, Mary Queen of Scots) and, especially after visiting his in-laws in Denmark, obsessed with the dangers of witchcraft. He sends witch hunters out into East Lothian to track down these wicked females. He orders witch trials and tortures, and interrogates the accused women himself. He even writes a book about it, Daemonologie (which later provides material for Macbeth.) Later, at masques in London, armed guards protect him. He and his courtiers speak in riddles, never quite meaning what they say. When, on James accession to the English throne, the Scottish court (and the Heriots) move to London, William Shakespeare becomes Court Playwright, and we are made even more aware of the fashion and the need for elliptical, oblique, dialogue. This is the way business is done, and life is led, at court.All is seen. All is known. They are all being watched.Most of the characters in this story are real, from the King himself to Shakespeare, Ben Jonson and Inigo Jones. A few have been invented for the good of the story, but so well imagined are they that they are every bit as convincing as the names with which we are familiar. Chief among them is Lady Marjorie Boswell, top rank manipulator and Georges wifes sister-in-law. He handles her with extreme caution and keeps Christian away from her:A queen bee must not only succeed herself, she must arrange that other women fall.
But perhaps Lady Marjorie is simply doing what she can with the hand shes been dealt; she reminds me a little of Becky Sharp. For when Findlay looks at the position of women in the 17th century, very little of it is good. Queen Anna may live a privileged life, but in return she must churn out potential heirs at a rate of knots for many will not survive. She has no privacy, even in childbirth instead the room is full of courtiers (to make sure the baby is not a switchling) who sit around eating, drinking and chatting while she endures her labour. For them it is theatre. For Anna, it is agony. She thinks of the witches she saw tortured and burned in her native Elsinore. Many women die in childbirth, many infants are stillborn or die in infancy. Midwives and other women who help women are frequently accused of witchcraft Anna dreads this happening to her own midwife.
And even if mother and child survive, a queens babies are not her own. They are immediately dispatched into the care of others. Annas Henry is sent to the Earl of Mar at Stirling Castle, partly for his education, partly for his protection. These are dangerous times.
Politics, and especially political relations between European countries, must be considered, and improved, at all times to avoid war (James is all for peace) and protect trade. But, as is said over four centuries later, its complicated. Spain wants an allegiance with Scotland to put James on the English throne, and marry Prince Henry Jamess heir off to a Spanish princess. But Spain is a Catholic country, and James has renounced his Catholic faith, partly to impress Elizabeth I, though he treads a fine line, and loathes Puritans. (Anna is less keen to give up the faith she was born to; James receives constant complaints about this, with the courtiers even saying that Annas favourite gentlewoman must be a Catholic because her brother is a poet) Catholics are persecuted; an horrific incident on a journey from Edinburgh to to London illustrates all too well what vicious cruelty such persecution can take. In an effort at appeasement (for he sees himself as a version of Solomon, and takes his Divine Right to rule very seriously) James commissions his own translation of the Bible; needless to say, more arguments ensue.
In the taverns, Ben Jonson hears talk that may ring more than a few modern bells:
We English need separation, independence, none of your wet alliances with Spain.England has never liked Europe.We do not need them, we can fight the world alone.
When the court moves to London, relations between James and the English courtiers are not always smooth. They mistrust him and struggle with his Scots dialect; they automatically assume that England is more important and powerful than Scotland. Annas name must be changed to Anne. James, in turn, packs Ben Jonson off to walk to Scotland, and insists on having porridge for breakfast.
As the courts extravagance reaches new heights, Heriot who profits greatly from the King and Queens excess begins to question this flagrant waste; there are, he knows, much better uses to which money could be put;
Heriot hears thatthe Masque of Blackness..cost over 100,000 enough to build a palace, or to educate the whole of Edinburgh.
The seed of an idea is sown. And as Heriots eventful life draws to a close, he makes the plans that will lead to the foundation of a school and also a hospital:
The main school will be called a hospital to cure the faitherless bairns as well as teach them. They cannot learn if they are sick.
The Queens Lender may be set in the 1600s, but its themes still resonate today. It is about power, suspicion, religious strife, persecution and conspiracy, but it is above all a very human story, one of love, loss, suffering and endurance, and of a thoroughly good man, the benefits of whose philanthropy are still felt in 21st century Edinburgh. In the words of the Kings Fool:
Curtain rise, and curtain fall, but the story goes on, and nothing finishes.
A most enjoyable book, fast-paced, informative, gripping and beautifully written, The Queens Lender by Jean Findlay will be published by Scotland Street Press on 14 February 2022.
-- Rosemary Kaye * The Edinburgh Review *
Jean Findlays The Queens Lender is a novel set in history, but fortunately for the lover of fiction, the book doesnt read like a historical text. In fact, events unfold themselves in the most effortless wayas if the reader is witnessing a play instead of reading silent words. Findlays characters are serious, like King James; extravagant, like Queen Anne; loyal and generous, like the protagonist George Heriot; cunning and calculating, like Lady Marjorie; and quite often also funny, like The Fool. In other words, these characters are the real deal, and Lady Marjorie seems so authentic that readers will be surprised to find out shes, in fact, Findlays invention, but only in the sense that its more probable for individuals with Marjories temperament to have existed at court, rather than not; in this way, she is real, meaning the novel reads like good fiction shouldits measured yet assertive, intellectually stimulating yet entertaining, and best of all funny without being grotesquely comical.
From the very beginning, readers find themselves engrossed in the world of George Heriot: Hes Queen Annas favorite jewel maker, and in time becomes not only her confidante, but also the royal familys money lenderhence the title of the book. Although readers will benefit from acquainting themselves beforehand with Elizabethan and Jacobean England, the novel can certainly be read without a minor historical background. Through her use of plot, dialogue, setting, and description, Findlay is able to situate the readerand this very comfortablyright into the main action.
The most wonderful thing about this book is that readers may not have intended to think historically, but they will invariably make discoveries, simply through the pleasure of reading the book alone. At the same time, those already quite familiar with the history of James VI of Scotland and I of England, will see things in a new light, precisely because of Findlays good sense to tell this story from the perspective of George Heriotan asymmetrical but aesthetically appealing choice; and so, the best praise one can bestow on Findlays novel is that its like discovering the story of Beowulf through the eyes of Grendel, in the sense that while figures like James, Anna, Shakespeare, and Ben Johnson might already be very familiar to most, their story, like Beowulfs, is rarely, if at all, told from a perspective other than their own. By using George Heriot as the eyes and ears of the court, Findlay uses her skills as a novelist to offer precisely this new perspective on a set of familiar historical events. In other words, what John Gardner did for Beowulf, Findlay has done for one of the most fascinating historical periods of the UK.
The novel begins so in Edinburgh, 1593: A pregnant woman is a fragile being, and George has two on his hands. His wife who keeps reminding him she is his queen and his Queen who is in fact his queen. From this sentence alone, readers can already get a small glimpse of Findlays witty, yet straightforward prose style. As the plot progresses, we find ourselves in a domain of shifting alliances, the birth and death of children, along with elation and grief; in this respect its also important to mention that while Findlay is leading us through a world inhabited mostly by the aristocracy and gentry, the jubilations and troubles we encounter in this milieu very much resemble our own. The concern, for instance, many of us have facedto remain safely at home or leave our places of comfort in search of greater opportunityisnt an existential burden restricted to the realm of the upper-class. Its a question many of us will face at some point in our own lives. George Heriot now has to decide whether he will follow his king to London, and thereby become the official jeweler of the court, or remain in Edinburgh, the city he loves and cherishes.
As we read on, a world much like our own reveals itself, full of divisions, rivalries, loyalty, and betrayal. In empires divided by religious affiliation, what will King James do? He can give in to the charms of his Bohemian ambassador and support a Protestant faction in a land ruled by the Hapsburgs, who are, in fact, supported by Spainnot only a Catholic country but also an ally to James. He can also remain loyal to Spain, but with this loyalty he will lose the support of not only the admired Bohemian ambassador, but also the entire Protest faction in that land, which he represents. While many of us will never have to undertake decisions that could influence the fate of entire nations, the existential burden of having to make difficult choices, where competing interests make it impossible not to offend those loyal to us, is something utterly and totally a part of our lives.
Findlay, as a historically aware novelist, has managed to capture the essence of a fascinating moment in time, but she has also done more than that: She has taken this history and presented it in such a way that the people within it could be individuals of our own timecharacters weve met ourselves. Take, for example, Lady Marjories son. Hes an aristocrat, but one whose supposedly excellent breeding wont allow for the politeness to take no for an answer. He attempts to sell George Heriot a horse the way a used car dealer wont stop haggling a customer who has accidentally wandered onto the lot. Though Heriot says he does not want nor need a horse, the good aristocrat wont quit until he receives a little compensation for the animal which that good jeweler once hired from the noblemans father. While we, ourselves, may not have been sold horses, and surely not that way, readers will nevertheless recognize the very same traits which cause our own contemporaries to sell us something with the same haughtinessmost likely a different, more efficient mode of transportation, such as the aforementioned car.
And then there are characters like Lord Lennox and Lord Douglastrendsetters, but not their own; they follow the trends of the most important people. When the former hears about the buttons recently designed for the Kings jacket, he naturally wants some for himself, naturally to wear them only the day after the King wears them in public, out of courtesy, of course; the latter meanwhile, also wants buttons like the Kings, but this time the trend has changed, and it has become amethyst and gold. Heriot, of course, like a good businessman, charges everyone upfront, except the royal family. Its, hence, the seemingly minor situations in the novel which show us a world much like our owna world full of greed, conformism, nepotism, but also of joy, family, and loyalty.
Findlays attention to detail is what really allows the story to come alive within the grand scheme of the history she situates her work in. Everything in this novel, as the late Harold Pinter used to say about good drama, has been cut to the bone. Theres no superfluous description or tedious dialogue that would make the reader stop and ask: Why? What purpose does this serve in helping me understand the larger aspects of the work? Her previous experience of working in theater is most likely what allowed Findlay to approach her fiction audience with a theater mentality. Just like one cannot expect someone to endure a tedious performance lasting one or two hours, its even more unreasonable to expect such patience when the effort is more solitary and lasts some days. Suffice it to say, with this novel Findlay has certainly earned the readers days.
-- David Garyan * International Literary Quarterly *
The Queens Lender, Jean Findlays latest novel, is a page-turner. I recommend it to all those interested in the turbulent years of the reign of James 6th of Scotland and 1st of England. The cover design by Antonia Shack is inspired by a portrait of Anne of Denmark by an unknown artist. Within its 201 pages, the world of Queen Anne and her husband King James is brought vividly to life. The story illuminates the life George Heriot through a host of characters, many of them speaking in the Broad Scots tongue in dramatic contrast to those speaking English. Jean Findlay is a master wordsmith and the novels storyline is revealed at breakneck speed. The text ascends to the condition of poetry and enabling me to see Jingling Geordie not so much as a moneylender but as a gifted craftsman. Also, I can now see him in relation to the world of William Shakespeare, Ben Johnson and William of Hawthornden, all inhabiting a world where death stalks in the form of plague, brutal execution and the perils of childbirth. The chapter entitled Sea Voyage dramatically reveals the terrors of the sea as George Heriots first wife Christian Heriot sails from Edinburgh to London in unimaginable pain and discomfort in which she endures agony of losing her two children, drowned in the tempestuous North Sea waters. Every politician in Scotlands Parliament should read this unforgettable novel. It should be required reading for every Scottish schoolchild.
-- Richard Demarco, CBE * Letter *
I love the character of George Heriot and felt a real ache at the end when he hopes for death and he longs to head to the woods... so lyrical and poetic! That, coupled with the setting of the royal court... the feeling that I am learning something of James V1s reign and character and the sheer poverty and cruelty of that era.. the appalling scene for example when George comes across the boy whose tongue has been cut out for praying with a rosary. I love the way Fraser pops in characters like Shakespeare and imagine exchanges..: The dialogue is especially good - Findlay has a real ear for language. And I have discovered a huge amount about jewellery too. A triumph and highly recommended.
-- Rachel Kelly * Amazon Review *
Its rare that I have such an immediate response to, and impression made by, a work of fiction but occasionally a novel comes along which is that pleasurable you almost feel compelled to return immediately to the first page and begin again. That is the minimum level of praise that The Queens Lender warrants; in all honesty, it deserves a great deal more. If this novel does not win a major award in the next publishing cycle, it will be a travesty and a disservice to the talents and intelligence of the author. Im effusive and unashamed in writing such a review.
Meet George Heriot, the Queens Lender. Based in Edinburgh, Heriot is a goldsmith by trade, royal-appointed jeweller and subsequently a philanthropist. A detail which the author brings to attention is that the role of the goldsmith in the seventeenth century was not just to produce jewels and precious metals but also to fulfil a number of other financial services to the monarch, thus Heriot becomes the Queens Banker. Mr Heriot holds the ear of the Queen as well as the purse strings, and both provide him with sufficient information and strategic knowledge to ensure that his fortune is made, yet despite this he serves dutifully and ably. Discretion sits well with debt in this case and whilst Heriot is depicted as a loyal servant, the reader is in no way deluded that Heriots main priority is the preservation of himself and his family.
Heriot ascends the ranks of the court, initially selling items to Anne of Denmark (Queen Consort) before his appointment to serve the Queen. Annes reputation for her love of jewellery is portrayed well, as is the lavish spending which was undertaken by her and James VI. What is significant about this portrayal of Heriot is the manner in which it illustrates how his philanthropic activity and considerations were borne out of concerns about the spendthrift and extravagant nature of the monarchys activities. He hears: the Masque of Blackness cost over 100,000 enough to build a palace, or to educate the whole of Edinburgh. It is at this point Findlay is able to offer Heriots counterpoint to the significant wealth he accrues and benefits from due to such expenditure.
Findlay is able to depict the tales of each critical member of the ruling family and their critical roles in the formation of the United Kingdom with a tenderness and humanity that is often markedly juxtaposed against the violence and brutality which characterised the court of James VI of Scotland. The young boy subjected to a brutal glossectomy for praying with a rosary is a harrowing but tender scene that sticks long in the memory.
Annes lack of financial acumen, Jamess paranoia about witchcraft and his subsequent purging of East Lothian, the appointment of the grandiloquent Shakespeare as Court Playwright and the broader commentary on the relationship between Europe and the United Kingdom gives this novel a timely resonance on the principles that history doesnt repeat itself, it simply rhymes. As Ben Jonson is heard to say: We English need separation, independence, none of your wet alliances with Spain England has never liked Europe We do not need them, we can fight the world alone. From the need to move away from ones home in order to prosper to the political division and nepotism which dominates, this astute piece of fiction is both in and out of its time.
The elegance of Findlays documenting this figure is enhanced by the laser-focused attention to his troubled private life as a father and husband who was often bereft of his wife and children by circumstances beyond his control, including death in childbirth and a childless marriage. At the point of Union and James Is decision to move to London, we see Heriots concern as to the consequence of his wifes travelling to London. This is a sequence where Findlays ability to bring the subject of her fiction to life, a touching and humane set of exchanges where the dialogue and scene-setting is delightful. She excels in conveying the environment and interrelationship between that and the emotions experienced by the characters, whether the reader is in the privacy of the Queens own chamber, a pungent fishmonger within the lively atmosphere of an Edinburgh street, an aromatic garden, or a claustrophobic and unsettled cabin in a ship sailing at the mercies of sea.
There is much more that could be said about The Queens Lender but this will hopefully sufficiently whet the appetite for the sumptuous feast of fiction that lies ahead for curious readers. Mr Heriots legacy has lived on through Heriots Hospital, George Heriots School and Heriot-Watt University. I expect that reputation to be burnished by this marvellous account of his life and the circumstances in which he lived.
-- Martyn Colebrook * The Bottle Imp *
The most surprising thing about Findlays fictionalized history of the court of King James Vl is its length. Historical novels tend to be colossal in size, ladenand sometimes weighed downwith facts and descriptions. But Findlays nimble work clocks in at less than 200 pages without losing any of its appeal...She leaves the reader wishing for more which is really all a writer can hope for.
* Kirkus *
