Cart
Free US shipping over $10
Proud to be B-Corp

Altruism in Private Law Jeroen Kortmann (Attorney at Law at Stibbe, Amsterdam, and a member of the Amsterdam Bar)

Altruism in Private Law By Jeroen Kortmann (Attorney at Law at Stibbe, Amsterdam, and a member of the Amsterdam Bar)

Summary

Examines two problems in Private law which are posed by the 'Good Samaritan'. This work examines and compares the varied responses of the Roman, French, German, and English legal systems to these problems.

Altruism in Private Law Summary

Altruism in Private Law: Liability for Nonfeasance and Negotiorum Gestio by Jeroen Kortmann (Attorney at Law at Stibbe, Amsterdam, and a member of the Amsterdam Bar)

This book examines two problems in Private law which are posed by the 'good Samaritan': First, do we have a legal duty to give aid to our fellow human beings? In particular: can we be held liable for damages if we fail to do so? Second, if we do come to the rescue, as the good Samaritan did, will we have any claim for the expenses that we incurred, or perhaps even for a reward? Kortmann examines and compares the varied responses of the Roman, French, German, and English legal systems to these problems, providing the first comprehensive treatment of English law in relation to 'liability for nonfeasance' (or 'liability for omissions') and 'negotiorum gestio' (or 'the doctrine of necessity'). In Part I, Kortmann examines English law which draws a distinction between action and inaction, or 'feasance' and 'nonfeasance'. In general, one is not held liable for failing to act. He explores the theoretical justifications for drawing this distinction and reveals through a short comparative survey the fundamentally different approaches taken in France and Germany, concluding that the English rule of no liability for nonfeasance requires a reconsideration. In Part II the English approach to the problem of reimbursement or reward is examined, detailing its profound differences from the Continental European approach. In principle, English law does not grant the necessitous intervener a claim against the beneficiary of his intervention. Kortamnn examines the theoretical justifications for assuming this position and again concludes that the law deserves reconsideration. Finally, Kortmann concludes by demonstrating close interconnections between the two, traditionally independent issues. He argues that the law ought not to introduce a general duty to intervene without at the same time granting the intervener a claim, at the very least for reimbursement of expenses and compensation of any loss suffered in the course of the intervention.

Altruism in Private Law Reviews

[This] book is to be welcomed as a carefully argued, at times imaginative, contribution to the continuing debate about the future annd shape of the English law of rescue. * Kevin Williams, Modern Law Review *
The author is to be commended for his lucid treatment of both doctrines, and for his subtle and convincing analysis of their interconnectedness * European Tort Law *
This slim, elegantly-argued volume presents a persuasive case for the reconsideration of both liability for nonfeasance and reimbursement for necessitous intervention in English Law
In a clear and elegant style, Kortmann has written a remarkable book in which he has developed a fine, sophisticated theory. It is to be hoped that the English courts will draw inspiration from it. * Professor J.H.A. Lokin, Ars Aequi *
An interesting read, based on considerable research. The account is thoughtful and thought-provoking and challenges the common lawyer to reassess his or her views on the topic of omissions.... Lord Goff in Smith v Littlewoods onceded that the legal treatment of omissions may one day need to be reconsidered. Kortmann eloquently puts the case for such a change. * Paula Giliker, King's College Law Journal *
[This book] certainly constitutes essential reading for any lawyer interested in the nature and effect of altruism in private law. * D.H. Van Zyl, Legal Studies *
Without doubt ... [Kortmann] deserves much praise for a book that is certain to captivate the reader. ... His arguments are well written and ...demonstrate a heartwarming erudition * Professor H.C.F. Schoordijk, Weekblad voor Privaatrecht, Notariaat en Registratie *

About Jeroen Kortmann (Attorney at Law at Stibbe, Amsterdam, and a member of the Amsterdam Bar)

Jeoren Kortmann has been a lecturer in Roman Law at The Queen's College, Oxford and is at present Attorney at Law at Stibbe, Amsterdam, and a member of the Amsterdam Bar.

Table of Contents

PART I: LIABILITY FOR NONFEASANCE ; I. INTRODUCTION ; II. WHAT IS 'NONFEASANCE'? ; III. THEORETICAL JUSTIFICATIONS FOR DISTINGUISHING BETWEEN FEASANCE AND NONFEASANCE ; IV. LIABILITY FOR NONFEASANCE IN CONTINENTAL EUROPEAN PRIVATE LAW ; V. LIABILITY FOR NONFEASANCE IN ENGLISH PRIVATE LAW ; VI. TOWARDS A MORE CONSISTENT APPROACH ; PART II: GRANTING A CLAIM TO THE INTERVENER ; VII. THE DIFFERENT MEASURES OF RECOVERY AND THEIR TERMINOLOGY ; VIII. THEORETICAL ARGUMENTS AGAINST GRANTING A REMEDY TO THE INTERVENER ; IX. THEORETICAL ARGUMENTS IN FAVOUR OF GRANTING A REMEDY TO THE INTERVENER ; X. THE CONTINENTAL DOCTRINE OF 'NEGOTIORUM GESTIO' ; XI. THE POSITION IN ENGLISH LAW ; XII. TOWARDS A GENERAL PRINCIPLE: USING THE EXISTING DOCTRINES? ; XIII. TOWARDS A NEW GENERAL PRINCIPLE ; EPILOGUE

Additional information

NPB9780199280056
9780199280056
0199280053
Altruism in Private Law: Liability for Nonfeasance and Negotiorum Gestio by Jeroen Kortmann (Attorney at Law at Stibbe, Amsterdam, and a member of the Amsterdam Bar)
New
Hardback
Oxford University Press
2005-02-24
228
N/A
Book picture is for illustrative purposes only, actual binding, cover or edition may vary.
This is a new book - be the first to read this copy. With untouched pages and a perfect binding, your brand new copy is ready to be opened for the first time

Customer Reviews - Altruism in Private Law