This important volume provides insights about the role of discussion in shaping policy and about how to study discussion empirically.
-Choice
As a theoretical and practical work, Asen's book should be required reading for educational policy-makers at the local and national level. It would also be of interest to citizens who wish to understand how market forces affect decision-making in public education and how local democratic practices might counter those forces.
-Stacie Molnar-Main, Journal of Public Deliberation
Emboldened by John Dewey's vision of a reciprocal relationship between education and democracy, Robert Asen invites the reader to join him and his colleagues in listening to how people talk during a series of local school-board meetings in Wisconsin. Participants struggle through some of their own differences, to be sure, but they also work through them enough to make collective, consequential decisions, using what Asen calls 'vernacular policy discourse.' This book compellingly captures the tone and spirit, as well as the pitfalls, of such deliberations. What happens in these meetings, we are told, is what democracy sounds like.
-Vanessa B. Beasley, Vanderbilt University
Populated by community members, school boards show how everyday citizens can (in the best of times) govern effectively and responsibly. In this book, Robert Asen shows us how the real work of democratic deliberation gets done in these local bodies. By looking directly at the micropolitics of school boards, Asen gets into the public debate on education down at the level where real decisions are made about local curricula, funding formulas, and more. We learn how the politics of 'holding schools accountable' plays out in local politics and how that relates to, but also distinguishes itself from, national policy debates.
-John W. Gastil, Pennsylvania State University
In Democracy, Deliberation, and Education, Robert Asen gives us an engaging, sympathetic account of the difficult decision making by school boards in three American communities. Written in a powerful, moving style and grounded in ideas from rhetoric, democratic theorizing, and educational policy debates, Asen's book compellingly shows how this scene of ordinary democratic deliberation, imperfect though it is, is nonetheless remarkable.
-Karen Tracy, University of Colorado
Combining fieldwork, rhetorical analysis, and democratic theory, Robert Asen has produced an insightful explication of the meaningful deliberative practices of local school boards. He ultimately reveals the messy and wonderful reality of actual decision-making processes as they develop within real democratic communities struggling over how to foster democracy's most important prerequisite-an educated citizenry. This work makes significant contributions to our understanding of both rhetorical deliberation and the vital role of education in how we imagine our democracy.
-Jay P. Childers, University of Kansas
Rob Asen's Democracy, Deliberation, and Education sets a new standard in studies of public deliberation due to its substance and depth. Students of public discourse from many fields will want to engage this lively and informative account. Asen's study, based on extensive fieldwork covering three school boards' deliberations over several years' time, is substantial, as he finds a register in which to unfold an account of their deliberations, identifying the intersections of their politics, history, and ideologies without reducing deliberation to any of these. His argument is deep, as he not only draws on the extensive literature and theory on deliberation to illuminate his cases, but also uses the cases to deepen a Deweyan account of situated deliberation.
-William M. Keith, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
Democracy, Deliberation, and Education provides a fascinating contribution to the study of rhetoric's role in contemporary politics. In a field dominated by either abstract theory or case studies focused on elite actors, Robert Asen shows us how rhetorical theory plays itself out in the humble but high-stakes world of local school board deliberations.
-Dave Tell, University of Kansas
A must-read for anyone interested in the rhetoric of public policy, the rhetoric of education, or the successful comingling of rhetorical and qualitative research methodologies.
-Mark Hlavacik, Rhetoric & Public Affairs
