Also the author of The History of Intentionality: Theories of Consciousness from Brentano through Husserl, 2007) Hickerson (Western Oregon Univ.) has written a complex and subtle treatment of what he calls doxastic sentimentalism, which is the theory that belief is not solely or primarily a cognitive state but also an affective state. In short, belief is as much a matter of feeling that one believes as it is anything else. Hickerson develops this thesis in conversation with empirical psychology and a variety of philosophers: Descartes, Husserl, and William James among others. The book is carefully argued and well written. . . Those working in the area will find it a useful contribution to the literature and well worth reading. Summing Up: Recommended. Graduate students, researchers, faculty.
* Choice *
There has been a slowly developing appreciation from various quarters in recent decades that the overlap between the philosophy of the emotions and epistemology might be greater than one would initially assume. Ryan Hickerson's Feelings of Believing: Psychology, History, and Phenomenology makes a timely and highly original contribution to this discussion. . . . Feelings of Believing is much more than just an excellent book for specialists. It is something quite rare in this day, namely, a good book of philosophy as such. With its readable, personable style, broad-ranging survey of topics and figures, and lucid exegesis and argument, generalists will find this book as enjoyable and educational as specialists will find it insightful and provocative. Its apparently niche topic and eclectic approach should not deter the general reader. This is an outstanding book for all students and researchers of philosophy.
* Journal of the History of Philosophy *
This groundbreaking book sets out to assess the prospects for doxastic sentimentalism--epistemologically, psychologically, phenomenologically, and historically. Nuanced, subtle, and trenchantly argued, Hickerson's book breaks new ground in exploring the rich and complex nexus of relationships between cognition and sentiment. -- Wayne Martin, University of Essex
Hickerson's Feelings of Believing is an ambitious work, and it fulfills these ambitions. It is historically sensitive, but with a modernizing eye, while also being empirically informed. It will appeal to a wide variety of scholars. -- Hsueh Qu, National University of Singapore
In this richly researched and carefully argued book, Ryan Hickerson draws upon the history of philosophy, contemporary empirical research, and robust phenomenological insights to defend both the prevalence and the plausibility of doxastic sentimentalism-the view that feeling is necessary for belief. It is mandatory reading for those interested in the psychology, epistemology, and phenomenology of belief. -- Walter Hopp, Boston University
Is there a characteristic feeling of believing? In this provocative and illuminating book, Hickerson retrieves a largely overlooked yet fruitful tradition of 'doxastic sentimentalism'. The result is an alternative history of modern epistemology that anyone thinking seriously about the nature of belief would benefit from. -- Joseph Schear, University of Oxford
